Ballotpedia Preferred Source

Democrats gain ground in state financial officer elections, with implications for ESG policy


Democrats won six Republican-held state financial offices in the November 3 elections, while Republicans won one Democratic office. Of the 49 elected offices on the ballot across 30 states, Democrats won 27 and Republicans won 22. Democrats secured a majority of the elected offices on the ballot, including eight of the 10 comptroller positions. Across all 69 directly elected state financial offices nationwide, however, Republicans will continue to hold a majority, with 39 offices compared to Democrats' 30.

State financial officers (SFOs) include treasurers, auditors, and comptrollers, whose responsibilities vary by state but generally include overseeing government finances, auditing public agencies, managing payments, and administering pension or trust funds. Some also oversee public investments, giving them influence over state investment policies, including the consideration of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors.

How did ESG factor into the elections?

Campaign issues varied by state, including fiscal accountability, government transparency, public investment management, and the responsibilities of financial offices.

In Indiana, incumbent Treasurer Daniel Elliott (R) defeated Coumba Kebe (D) 51.1% to 48.9% in a race that highlighted differing approaches to ESG investing. Elliott has supported restrictions on ESG considerations in public investments, including placing BlackRock on a state watchlist in 2024 over alleged ESG commitments, which BlackRock disputed. The Indiana Public Retirement System's board, on which Elliott serves, subsequently voted to replace BlackRock as manager of a roughly $969 million bond portfolio. Elliott emphasized financial returns as the primary consideration in investment decisions, while Kebe advocated greater transparency regarding investment costs and risks, and argued that workforce practices can affect long-term financial performance.

In Texas, Sarah Eckhardt (D) defeated the incumbent Comptroller Don Huffines (R) 51.3% to 46.2%, giving Democrats control of the office for the first time since 1999. The Texas comptroller administers the state's list of financial companies determined to boycott energy companies under state law, making the change in leadership particularly relevant to ongoing debates over ESG-related investment restrictions. The election does not itself change those statutory requirements, but the incoming comptroller's approach to implementing them will be worth watching.

In Connecticut, incumbent Treasurer, Erick Russell (D) won reelection against Fred Wilms (R) 59.2% to 40.8% in a race where ESG investing was a central issue. Russell defended considering ESG factors when managing the state's approximately $69 billion in public pension assets, arguing that ESG considerations can support long-term investment returns. Wilms opposed using ESG factors in pension investment decisions and proposed creating an investment board to share fiduciary responsibilities with the treasurer.

What's next for state financial policy?

The election results could influence state policies concerning pension investments, financial institutions, and ESG considerations. Republican financial officers have supported restrictions on ESG investing, while some Democratic officials have defended considering financially material ESG risks in investment decisions.

As newly elected officials assume office, their approaches to public investment oversight and the implementation of existing ESG-related laws will be important to watch. In Texas, for example, the comptroller's office has added and removed financial companies from its energy-boycott list, illustrating how administrative decisions can affect the application of state investment restrictions. However, the extent of any policy changes will depend on individual officeholders' priorities, statutory requirements, and the authority shared with pension boards and other state agencies.

Ballotpedia tracks support for and opposition to the environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) investing movement. To learn more about arguments for, against, and about ESG, click here. For more information on reform proposals related to ESG policy, click here.