Ballotpedia Preferred Source

How the 2026 elections affected state supreme courts: Ohio


In Ohio, Democrats won both Ohio Supreme Court seats on the 2026 ballot. These wins included re-electing incumbent Justice Jennifer L. Brunner (D), whose race was expected to be close going into Nov. 3. As of writing, Brunner won her race by 2.7 points, making this her narrowest win to the court. Ohioans also elected Marilyn Zayas (D), who defeated incumbent Dan Hawkins (R). Hawkins first won his seat on the court in a 2024 special election. Zayas, a newcomer to the court, gives the Ohio Supreme Court two Democrats for the first time since 2024. After Zayas is sworn in, the court will have a 5-2 Republican majority.

In addition to flipping a state supreme court seat, Democrats won the Ohio governorship for the first time in two decades. The last time a Democratic governor was elected was in 2006, when Ted Strickland defeated J. Kenneth Blackwell (R) by more than 20 points. Twenty years later, Amy Acton (D) defeated Vivek Ramaswamy (R) and Don Kissick (L) in the 2026 Ohio gubernatorial election. As of writing, Acton won the seat by 7.9 points, a nearly 33-point swing from 2022. Acton, who previously worked as a physician and as the director of the Ohio Department of Health, will be responsible for filling any judicial vacancies that occur during her tenure. Her term will end in January 2031, unless she is re-elected in 2030.

Whether Acton will get the opportunity to fill any vacancies, however, remains uncertain. Outgoing Gov. Mike DeWine (R) only had one opportunity to fill a vacancy on the state’s highest court during his eight-year tenure, when voters elected Sharon L. Kennedy (R) as chief justice. Ohio is one of 23 states that have a separate seat for the chief justice of their supreme courts. Because of this, Justice Kennedy vacated her previous position as associate justice to accept the title of chief justice, giving Gov. DeWine the opportunity to appoint her successor.

At least two justices will reach Ohio’s mandatory judicial retirement age while Acton is in office. Justices Pat Fischer (R) and Joseph Deters (R) will reach age 70 during Acton’s first term as governor. Under the Ohio Constitution, justices may serve the remainder of their term if they reach the mandatory retirement age during their tenure. Fischer’s term ends in 2028, giving the justice a little more than two years left on the court. Should he serve the remainder of his tenure on the court, Fischer's seat will be open for a partisan election in November 2028. However, should Fischer choose to retire before his term is up, Acton would have the ability to appoint his successor, giving Democrats an opportunity to flip his seat on the court. Similarly, Deters, who last won re-election in 2024, can continue to serve until his term ends in 2031. Unless Deters vacates his seat before his term ends, his seat will be open for a 2030 partisan election. It is unclear what each justice plans to do following the 2026 elections.

The gains mark a shift for the Ohio Democratic Party in a state that has trended more conservative for nearly 20 years. Ohio has had a Republican trifecta since 2011, and between 2009 and 2025, it elected only one Democrat to statewide non-judicial office: Sherrod Brown, the state's former and incoming U.S. senator. Brown was first elected to the U.S. Senate in 2006, defeating then-incumbent Mike DeWine (R). He won re-election in 2012 and 2018 but lost his seat to Bernie Moreno (R) in 2024 by 3.6 points. Following that defeat, Brown ran for Ohio's other U.S. Senate seat in a 2026 special election. He won the Democratic primary with 89% of the vote and defeated the appointed incumbent Jon Husted (R) by 4.9 points, as of writing.

Additional reading: