In this week’s edition of Economy and Society:
- Democrats gain ground in state financial officer elections, with implications for ESG policy
- Texas dismisses lawsuit against proxy adviser Glass Lewis
- COP31 electrification target faces resistance
- Royal Bank of Canada eliminates senior climate and ESG positions
- Sustainalytics assigns Anthropic high ESG risk rating ahead of IPO
In the states
Democrats gain ground in state financial officer elections, with implications for ESG policy
What’s the story?
Democrats won six Republican-held state financial offices in the Nov. 3 elections, while Republicans won one Democratic office. Of the 49 elected offices on the ballot across 30 states, Democrats won 27 and Republicans won 22. Democrats secured a majority of the elected offices on the ballot. Across all 69 directly elected state financial offices nationwide, however, Republicans will continue to hold a majority, with 39 offices compared to Democrats' 30.
State financial officers (SFOs) include treasurers, auditors, and comptrollers, whose responsibilities vary by state but generally include overseeing government finances, auditing public agencies, managing payments, and administering pension or trust funds. Some also oversee public investments, giving them influence over state investment policies, including the consideration of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors.
How did ESG factor into the elections?
Campaign issues varied by state, including ESG investing, fiscal accountability, government transparency, public investment management, and the responsibilities of financial offices.
In Indiana, incumbent Treasurer Daniel Elliott (R) defeated Coumba Kebe (D) 51.1% to 48.9% in a race that highlighted differing approaches to ESG investing. Elliott has supported restrictions on ESG considerations in public investments, including by placing BlackRock on a state watchlist in 2024 over alleged ESG commitments, which BlackRock disputed. The Indiana Public Retirement System's board, on which Elliott serves, subsequently voted to replace BlackRock as manager of a roughly $969 million bond portfolio. Elliott emphasized financial returns as the primary consideration in investment decisions, while Kebe advocated greater transparency regarding investment costs and risks and argued that workforce practices can affect long-term financial performance.
In Texas, Sarah Eckhardt (D) defeated the incumbent Comptroller Don Huffines (R) 51.3% to 46.2%, giving Democrats control of the office for the first time since 1999. The Texas comptroller maintains a list of financial companies the office determines are boycotting energy companies under state law, making the change in leadership particularly relevant to ongoing debates over ESG-related investment restrictions. The election does not itself change those statutory requirements, but the incoming comptroller's approach to implementing them will be worth watching.
In Connecticut, incumbent Treasurer Erick Russell (D) won re-election against Fred Wilms (R) 59.2% to 40.8% in a race where ESG investing was a central issue. Russell defended considering ESG factors when managing the state's approximately $69 billion in public pension assets, arguing that ESG considerations can support long-term investment returns. Wilms opposed using ESG factors in pension investment decisions and proposed creating an investment board to share fiduciary responsibilities with the treasurer.
What's next for state financial policy?
The election results could influence state policies concerning pension investments, financial institutions, and ESG considerations. Republican financial officers have supported restrictions on ESG investing, while some Democratic officials have defended considering financially material ESG risks in investment decisions.
As newly elected officials assume office, their approaches to public investment oversight and the implementation of existing ESG-related laws will be important to watch. In Texas, for example, the comptroller's office has added and removed financial companies from its energy-boycott list, illustrating how administrative decisions can affect the application of state investment restrictions. However, the extent of any policy changes will depend on individual officeholders' priorities, statutory requirements, and the authority shared with pension boards and other state agencies.
Texas dismisses lawsuit against proxy adviser Glass Lewis
What’s the story?
On Nov. 9, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) dismissed the state’s lawsuit against proxy advisory firm Glass Lewis with prejudice, meaning the state cannot refile the same claims. Paxton filed the lawsuit on July 13, alleging that Glass Lewis violated the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA) by presenting its proxy voting recommendations as objective while prioritizing its own ESG agenda. The complaint challenged the firm's voting guidelines, including recommendations concerning corporate board diversity and climate-related risks.
Glass Lewis denied the allegations. Following the dismissal, a company representative said, “We welcome the Attorney General’s decision to dismiss with prejudice the State of Texas’s unfounded lawsuit under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act.” The representative added, “As always, Glass Lewis remains committed to providing our clients with the research and analysis they need to make informed voting decisions.”
No court made findings on whether Glass Lewis violated Texas law. The reporting did not establish why Paxton dismissed the lawsuit or whether the dismissal followed a settlement.
Texas also sued Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) in May 2026, alleging that the firm prioritized ESG considerations over clients’ financial interests. No dismissal of that separate lawsuit has been confirmed.
Why does it matter?
The dismissal ends one of Texas’ two consumer protection lawsuits challenging proxy advisory firms’ use of ESG considerations. It does not resolve broader legal disputes over states’ authority to regulate proxy voting advice.
The state lawsuits are separate from the federal constitutional challenge to Texas’ 2025 proxy adviser disclosure law, SB 2337. ISS and Glass Lewis challenged that law, arguing that its requirements violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments. A federal judge temporarily blocked enforcement against the firms in August 2025.
What’s the background?
In 2025, Texas enacted SB 2337, requiring proxy advisory firms to make certain disclosures when their recommendations consider nonfinancial factors, including ESG and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) considerations.
ISS and Glass Lewis filed federal lawsuits challenging the law in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas. In August 2025, U.S. District Judge Alan Albright temporarily blocked its enforcement against the two firms. Texas subsequently withdrew its appeals of the preliminary injunctions in November 2025, while the underlying federal litigation continued.
Paxton also sued ISS in May 2026 under the DTPA, alleging that the firm misrepresented the objectivity of its proxy voting recommendations while advancing ESG-related policies.
Around the world
COP31 electrification target faces resistance
What’s the story?
Negotiators at the United Nations COP31 climate conference in Antalya, Turkey, are divided over a proposal to increase electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035. COP31 is the 31st Conference of the Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change.
The COP31 presidency released an 18-page draft agreement on Nov. 16, drawing on proposals submitted by participating countries as negotiators began the second week of the conference. The presidency proposed that countries contribute, in a nationally determined manner, to increasing electricity's share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035. The proposal would establish a global goal without imposing individual targets or obligations on participating countries.
The Arab Group, a negotiating bloc representing 22 Arab countries, and another bloc that includes China, India, and Saudi Arabia opposed including new sector-specific targets in the final COP31 agreement, such as the electrification proposal. The initiative has received support from about 30 countries, although a complete list of supporters has not been released.
The draft also “calls for accelerated action to phase out fossil fuels, including through the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems”. That language remains under negotiation and could change before countries consider a final agreement.
The Nov. 16 document is an initial negotiating draft rather than an agreed COP31 outcome. Australian Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen, who is leading the COP31 negotiations, said the draft was intended to identify where countries could and could not reach agreement, and its provisions may change substantially before the conference concludes. Any final COP31 decision requires consensus among participating countries.
Why does it matter?
The disagreement could determine whether COP31 formally endorses a global electrification benchmark and how closely that goal is connected to reducing fossil-fuel use.
One point of contention is whether the 35% target should specifically require additional electricity to come from cleaner energy sources. The draft separately calls for increased clean electrification, but does not explicitly tie that requirement to the 35% target. Opposition from some countries has complicated efforts to strengthen that connection.
More than 180 companies, including H&M Group, IKEA, Danone, Uber, Schneider Electric, and Volvo Cars, called on governments ahead of COP31 to accelerate clean electrification and make it a central part of economic and industrial policy. The companies represented about $1.69 trillion in combined annual revenue.
The We Mean Business Coalition, which organized the statement, said 69% of business leaders it surveyed reported that their companies were electrifying faster than governments were preparing for. The group said electricity costs, grid constraints, inconsistent policies, and slow implementation were among the factors limiting deployment.
What’s the background?
COP31 began Nov. 9 in Antalya under a joint arrangement between Turkey and Australia. After both countries sought to host the conference, they reached a compromise in November 2025 giving Turkey the presidency, led by Environment Minister Murat Kurum, and Australia responsibility for leading formal negotiations under Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen. The presidency oversees the conference and sets its broader agenda.
The COP31 presidency made electrification one of the conference’s priorities through its 35 by 35 initiative. The initiative seeks to increase electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035 through nationally determined policies and actions. Estimates of electricity’s current share vary, with the COP31 presidency using approximately 23% and other reports describing it as just over 20%.
Royal Bank of Canada eliminates senior climate and ESG positions
What’s the story?
Royal Bank of Canada (RBC), Canada's largest bank, eliminated at least three senior climate and ESG positions as part of a broader corporate reorganization.
The eliminated positions included vice presidents of climate strategy, ESG risk, and sustainability strategy and performance. RBC created a new public policy group that absorbed its climate team and moved sustainability reporting into its finance division. The bank said approximately six employees lost their jobs because of overlapping responsibilities.
RBC representative Andrew Block said the bank had "moved the climate team in its entirety into a newly created Public Policy group to give us a stronger voice with more impact on important policy issues, with climate and sustainability as its main focus."
The new public policy group, led by Vice President Emily Head, will also oversee issues including artificial intelligence, payments, and fraud prevention.
Why does it matter?
The reorganization follows a broader retreat from climate and ESG initiatives among North American banks. RBC withdrew from the Net-Zero Banking Alliance in 2025 and abandoned its sustainable finance goals that year, citing changes to Canada's Competition Act that it said restricted what information the bank could disclose.
RBC said its business teams would continue working on climate commitments and helping clients transition to lower-emission operations. Richard Brooks, climate finance director at environmental advocacy organization Stand.earth, said the restructuring could reduce the bank's specialized climate expertise and dilute its focus.
On Wall Street and in the private sector
Sustainalytics assigns Anthropic high ESG risk rating ahead of IPO
What’s the story?
Morningstar Sustainalytics, an ESG ratings provider, assigned Anthropic, an artificial intelligence company, a high ESG risk rating ahead of the company’s planned initial public offering (IPO). An IPO is when a private company sells shares to the public for the first time, typically by listing on a stock exchange. Anthropic expects to price its offering Nov. 18 and begin trading on Nasdaq under the ticker ANT on Nov. 19.
Anthropic received a score of 32.1 on Sustainalytics’ 100-point scale, which measures how much a company's financial value is exposed to ESG risks that it has not adequately managed. Higher scores indicate greater unmanaged risk. Scores between 30 and 40 fall into the high-risk category, the second-highest classification.
Sustainalytics identified business ethics and workforce management as Anthropic’s primary sources of ESG risk. Business ethics accounted for 25% of its overall risk score, while human capital accounted for 21%.
Sustainalytics said, “Anthropic is exposed to elevated ethical risks due to its reliance on large-scale data collection and web scraping, including use of copyrighted content in model training.” The ratings provider also identified potential litigation, regulatory compliance costs, and competition for specialized engineering talent as concerns.
Why does it matter?
Sustainalytics' ratings can influence which companies ESG-focused investment funds include in their portfolios. Some exchange-traded funds (ETFs) follow indexes that use the ratings to select or exclude companies. For example, Morningstar's Sustainability Indexes exclude companies with severe ESG risk ratings and prioritize those with lower risk scores. Anthropic's high-risk designation does not automatically disqualify it, but could affect its eligibility or selection for ESG-focused funds after its IPO.
In a report on Anthropic and OpenAI, Sustainalytics examined governance, safety, transparency, and regulatory risks facing the companies as they approach public markets. The report identified these factors as potential considerations for investors evaluating AI companies, particularly as regulatory requirements and demand for AI services evolve.
Sustainalytics rated Anthropic’s risks as low or negligible in other categories, including data privacy and cybersecurity, product governance, and corporate governance.

