After a spokesperson for Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger (D) said on Nov. 13 that the state will not complete the steps required for it to participate in the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit program in 2027, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the state is required to under federal law, setting up a conflict over whether states have the ability to do so.
To participate in 2027, the first year of the program, states must complete Internal Revenue Service (IRS) advance elction Form 15714 by Jan. 1, 2027, then submit a list of the state's scholarship-granting organizations (SGOs) to the IRS by Feb. 15, 2027.
Former Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin (R) opted the state in and Virginia became the first state to complete Form 15714, doing so on Jan. 9, 2026, just days before Spanberger took office. On Nov. 13, a representative for Spanberger said her administration will not submit a list of SGOs and that the state will not participate in 2027 because her administration does not believe the program will benefit public school students.
On Nov. 15, Bessent responded to Virginia's announcement on X: "Virginia has already elected to participate in 2027, and @GovernorVA is required under federal law to complete the administrative process. Governor Spanberger: certify the scholarship organizations. Stop playing politics with children’s futures."
Treasury is in the process of collecting comments before issuing a final regulation — expected in 2028 — to implement the program; the proposed regulations will govern the program in 2027. States must opt into the program annually, and the staggered deadlines for state participation is unique to 2027. Starting in 2028, the deadline for both an advance election and the SGO list will be Jan. 1, meaning it's unlikely that an advance election and an SGO list submission would be completed by different governors.
As of Nov. 17, 32 states have indicated they'd participate in 2027 – 23 with Republican trifectas, four with Democratic trifectas (including Virginia), and five with divided governments.
Post-election participation landscape
The conflict over whether states may let an election to participate through Form 15714 lapse could apply in more state than just Virginia as a result of the Nov. 3 election.
Before the election, 30 states, including 23 with Republican trifectas, had formally opted into the FSTC program. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) also said New York would participate, but, as of Nov. 13, had not officially opted in by submitting the advance election form. Gubernatorial elections took place in 19 of those 30 states, and participation in the program was a campaign issue in several of them, including Michigan and Arizona. As a result of the election, control of the governorship in five states that had opted into the FSTC — Georgia, Iowa, Nevada, Ohio, and Texas — changed from Republicans to Democrats.
Outgoing governors may choose to submit the required forms and submit the SGO list before they're sworn out, or leave this choice to their successor. Incoming governors who take office after Jan. 1 — all but five — cannot opt in if their predecessor doesn't submit the advance election form by Jan. 1. It is unclear whether governors have the option not to finalize participation by submitting an SGO list before the February deadline if the outgoing governor has not done so. That would leave their state's participation incomplete, as announced in Virginia.
Taxpayers in states that do not participate can still donate and claim the tax credit, but SGOs will not be authorized to disburse or award scholarship funds in that state.
Sixteen of the 19 states that had not indicated whether they would participate in the program before Nov. 3 had gubernatorial elections. Partisan control did not change in any of those states: Democrats maintained control in 15 states, and Gov. Phil Scott (R) won re-election in Vermont.
On Nov. 4, outgoing New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham (D) — who was term-limited — announced that she would opt New Mexico into the program and her administration would certify SGOs for participation. Debra Haaland (D) will assume office on Jan. 1, 2027. No other states or governors had moved to participate in the program after the election.
Eight states — Idaho, Indiana, Oklahoma, Kansas, Kentucky, North Carolina, New Hampshire, and Tennessee — have state laws requiring the state to opt in to the program. Laws in five — Idaho, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, and New Hampshire — require the state to opt in annually.
Democrats have been slower to opt into the program, though some have. Several Democratic governors indicated they would wait on the regulations before deciding if their states would participate. After the IRS issued regulations on Oct. 2, Hochul confirmed New York’s intention to opt in to the program and Lujan Grisham submitted Form 15714, while one other Democratic governor – Oregon Gov. Tina Kotek, who won re-election on Nov. 3 – said that state would not participate.
Reactions to Spanberger's announcement
On Nov. 14, Youngkin's team said on X that it did everything it could to participate, and the final SGO certification step was not available while he was in office.
However, Diane Ravitch, former U.S. Assistant Secretary of Education and education policy analyst, agreed with Spanberger's decision not to participate in the program. She said that while the program may benefit public school students, it was built to fund private education.
"The federal voucher program is designed to subsidize children in religious and other private schools. Public schools are allowed to seek subsidies for miscellany like after-school tutoring, but that’s a pittance compared to the subsidies for non-public school tuition."
Chad Aldeman, an education finance policy writer, disagreed with Spanberger's decision, said the program has clear benefits for public school students, and said that he himself was working to establish an SGO to fund tutoring for students in high-poverty public schools.
"Now, there is a lot of uncertainty here about just how much public school students stand to benefit. But part of that uncertainty stems from policymaker inaction. In fact, the governor’s indecision throughout 2026 is part of the reason that the public sector could not be more active. Why bother going through the work of creating a Scholarship Granting Organization if you’re not sure if it will be allowed to give money locally?"
Perspectives on participation
In Virginia and elsewhere, perspectives on whether Democratic-led states will participate often focus on how the program would benefit public schools students. Some say the program will harm public schools by decreasing enrollment — and, therefore, funding — while others say the program will bring more money to public schools and not participating could disadvantage those students.
President of the Virginia Education Association Carol Bauer, upon the release of the regulations, discouraged Gov. Spanberger from participating, saying that participating would "would take nearly a billion dollars out of our public schools."
Arne Duncan, Senior fellow at Democrats for Education Reform — a political action committee that says Democrats should opt in as soon as possible — and a former U.S. Secretary of Education, says public school students will benefit and that Democratic unwillingness to participate would only weaken their ability to shape the program's outcomes.
He said: "Treasury’s rules confirm what we’ve anticipated for a while now: public school students will benefit. No program is perfect, but the only way to shape this one and make sure it works for the kids who need it most is to opt in. Republicans have sold fear. We have to sell excellence and show parents we’re fighting for their child. Democratic governors should be leaping at the chance to close the gap and own education again."
Marguerite Roza, Research Professor at Georgetown University and Director of the Edunomics Lab, also said that participating states will have more opportunity to affect the program's structure and determine who benefits.
While Roza said she didn't think the IRS would respond quickly to a Oct. 22 letter from five Democratic governors who have not opted in asking for more details about the program, she said states that are opted in could have leverage to make the program address their concerns: "For those governors that have hesitations but opt in anyway, a smart move would be to establish clear criteria under which their state will stay in the following year. One of those criteria might be that school districts and the students they serve see a clear benefit from the program."
Miguel Cardona, another former U.S. Secretary of Education and head of an education consulting firm, and Robert Kim, executive director of Education Law Center, said the regulations will not make the program workable for public school students.
They said, "We urge all governors and state leaders to steer clear of this dangerous federal scheme, which is nothing more than a Trojan horse that will gut public schools under the guise of a gift. ... Much has been written about how public schools and students can supposedly benefit from the program. But the measly sum that may reach public school students is certainly not worth pushing private education voucher programs into states that don’t currently have them."
More on the program
The FSTC is a dollar-for-dollar nonrefundable tax credit, meaning individuals can lower their federal tax liability by $1 for every $1 donated to accredited SGOs up to certain limits. SGOs distribute the donated scholarship funds to eligible families for a variety of private or public educational expenses, including private school tuition, tutoring services, textbooks, and more. To qualify for scholarships, students had to live in households earning no more than 300% of the area's median gross income and be eligible to enroll in K-12 schools. The program will begin on Jan. 1, 2027.
States that elect to participate must submit a list of SGOs that taxpayers can donate to in order to receive the federal tax credit. Students in states that do not opt in cannot receive scholarships funded under the program, but donors in those states can still receive a federal tax credit by donating to SGOs in participating states.
The IRS is finalizing proposed rules for the program — with a public hearing on Dec. 15 — and expects to issue further guidance defining eligible expenses. In addition to changes in state government, election results may affect the program's future in Congress, where legislation in the Senate to repeal the program has 36 co-sponsors, and a House version has 116, all Democrats.


