Welcome to the Wednesday, June 28, Brew.
Here’s what’s in store for you as you start your day:
- Special congressional elections have become more common in recent decades
- Democrats and Republicans contesting 51% of state legislative elections this year, down from 93% in 2021
- Louisianans to decide amendment on religious gatherings in response to COVID-19 pandemic
Special congressional elections have become more common in recent decades
The number of special congressional elections has increased steadily over the past three decades, from an average of 7.6 special elections in the five meetings after redistricting in the 1990s to an average of 13.4 in the five meetings after redistricting in the 2010s.
The trend towards more special elections is true for both the U.S. House and Senate. The average number of House special elections increased from 6.2 in the 1990s to 11.0 in the 2010s. For the Senate, the average increased from 1.4 to 2.4 during that time.
A congressional special election takes place when an incumbent resigns, dies, or is removed from office. The Constitution requires that all vacancies in the U.S. House be filled through an election.
But states get to decide how to fill Senate vacancies, with only 13 requiring a special election. In the remaining 37, the governor makes an appointment to fill the vacancy temporarily. After that, the state holds an election at the next regularly-scheduled date to fill out the remainder of the term.
The 118th Congress began in January of this year. Since then, one special election has already been held in Virginia, and two are upcoming in Rhode Island and Utah. There will also be an election in 2024 in Nebraska to fill out the remaining two years of former U.S. Sen. Ben Sasse’s (R) term. Gov. Jim Pillen (R) appointed Pete Ricketts (R) to fill that vacancy earlier this year.
Democrats and Republicans contested 51% of state legislative elections this year, down from 93% in 2021
Based on candidate filing deadline data available for 434 of the 578 state legislative seats up for election this year, 51% (220) will come down to a general election contest between Democrats and Republicans in November.
The remaining 49% (214) are effectively guaranteed to either Democrats (99) or Republicans (115) because they lack competition from the other major party.
This is a marked change from 2021, when 93% of elections had major party competition. But, as things stand, it does represent an increase from the 2019 election cycle, when only 44% of seats featured both a Democrat and a Republican.
These numbers will change. Candidates might drop out or be added to the ballot over the coming months. Plus, for 2023, we won’t have data from Louisiana until after its Aug. 10 filing deadline. Historically, the state has had a low rate of major party competition, ranging from 16% to 25% over the past decade.
The fluctuations in the graphic above are due primarily to the calendar with off-year elections. While New Jersey and Virginia hold elections every two years, Louisiana and Mississippi hold them every four years, corresponding to 2011, 2015, 2019, and 2023 above.
Over the past decade, the percentage of seats contested with major party competition has decreased steadily in Mississippi and New Jersey, dropping 20 and 10 percentage points in both states, respectively, since 2011.
In Virginia, the rate has increased 30 percentage points during that same time, with a decade-high 91% of seats contested by both major parties in 2021.
In even-numbered years, the percentage of seats with major party competition has ranged from 56% (2014) to 65% (2010, 2020). Last year, 59% of state legislative seats had major party competition.
When comparing odd-year election cycles to their preceding even-year cycles, New Jersey routinely ranks as one of the most competitive states in terms of major party competition.
Comparing 2018 and 2019 percentages, New Jersey ranked fourth, Virginia ranked 34th, and Louisiana and Mississippi ranked 49th and 50th, respectively.
Comparing 2022 and 2023 percentages, again, New Jersey ranks fourth and Mississippi ranks last, with Virginia moving up to 18th.
You can learn more about major party competition in last year’s state legislative elections here, and more about this year’s state legislative elections, in general, using the link below.
Louisianans to decide amendment on religious gatherings in response to COVID-19 pandemic
In October, Louisiana voters will decide on a constitutional amendment defining the ability to worship in a church or other place of worship as a constitutional right. The state constitution already establishes a right to religious freedom, but this amendment would further define that right to include gathering in places of worship.
State Sen. Beth Mizell (R) introduced the amendment—Senate Bill 63—on May 2, 2023, in response to public health actions taken during the coronavirus pandemic. Mizell said, “In the latest action that we went through with the pandemic, churches were the last gathering place that were allowed to open.”
Gov. John Bel Edwards (D) issued a stay-at-home order for Louisiana in March 2020, which ultimately limited public or private gatherings of more than 10 people. The Louisiana Supreme Court declared that order unconstitutional in 2022 in a case involving a reverend who was charged with misdemeanors for holding religious services while the order was in place.
In a letter opposing the proposed amendment, the New Orleans Secular Humanist Association’s Marty Bankson wrote, “The only issue that this might be relevant to is that of government restrictions … for health … or other public safety concerns — but I’m sure Mizell would not risk the wellbeing of her fellow citizens for the sake of going to church for a few days.”
This amendment follows similar pandemic-response measures in Texas and Arkansas. Texans approved an amendment prohibiting limitations on religious services, 62-38%, in 2021, while Arkansans rejected an amendment regarding limiting how government rules can affect religious freedom, 50.4-49.6%, in 2022.
Louisianans decided 56 constitutional amendments from 1999 to 2021, approving 37 (66%) and rejecting 19 (34%).